If you watch this, you're in deep...
I'm going to get grief for this one. How can I put a true story where real people died on a list with a terrible comedy starring Mike Epps? I blame it on a medical condition. Over the course of the past half decade I've somehow developed
a very serious allergic reaction to Peter Berg. If you don't think you know who he is, I bet you do. He's the former actor who directed "Very Bad Things", "The Rundown", "Friday Night Lights", "The Kingdom", "Hancock", and that modern classic,
"Battleship."
I happen to like "Very Bad Things" and "Friday Night Lights" but somewhere along Berg's maturing as a director he stopped maturing and is now inhabiting this very particular niche I find annoying. Let's start with his maturation:
his movies all look the same. Go back and watch his entire imdb filmography and you'll see shaky cam, overexposure, quick cuts and scene after scene of characters exchanging mundane banter which is clearly either improv or meant to sound like improv.
He does this purposely and, I guess, purposefully, to great an 'authentic' feel for his movies.
His technique worked for the very small, intimate story of "Friday Night Lights" and even "Very Bad Things" but not so much for "The Rundown,"
which is an action movie. Action movies which look and 'feel' real end up being quiet boring to look at (think anything Michael Mann does which is more action than drama: Blackhat and Miami Vice, for instance). By the time he got to his first big
budget film, "The Kingdom," I started to see the limitations of his choices. "The Kingdom" takes place in Saudia Arabia but he shoots it like it takes place in the same small town as "Friday Night Lights."
"Hancock" was better because of the subject matter. it was subversive. Hancock was a superhero but one
who existed in the 'real world' and his heroics reflect that. It was okay then that the whole thng was shot like an episode of Cops and that the fantastic was seen through security tapes and news channel helicopters.
But then came Battleship.
This is a story about an alien invasion. It's supposed to be extraordinary and the movie sufferred because Berg's directing style demanded it stay grounded. I didn't want realistic, I wanted ridiculous, and Berg's inability to change the prism through which he views (and
shows) a world, couldn't deliver that.
So what is a good director to do when he has a very limited range? Well, pick projects that play to your strengths. So Berg began the 'based on a true story' part of his career. It's okay that
he shoots everything as if it is 'real' because it WAS real. That makes sense, right?
"Lone Survivor" came first in 2013 and I liked it. But my b.s. detector started working overtime during the last 20 minutes. There's a huge battle
between good guys and bad guys which I suspected, and I've since confirmed, never happened. It feels forced, like it belongs in a typical action movie. But that's a script issue, and I don't blame Berg for that. What I do blame him for is that
when the movie turns into an action film, his directing style can't keep up. As misguided as it might be, the script calls for an epic last battle and he shoots it like it's a robbery at a Seven Eleven.
Now comes Deepwater Horizon and Patriots Day. Both came out this year and both are true stories. Theoritically,
his directing style would be a good fit but here's where my allergy comes in. He's playing it safe. And when a director plays it safe, they get lazy. And when they get lazy, all of the urgency and passion in the movie is sucked out. You may
not notice if the script is good enough or if the action is distracting enough, but you do notice when the story is small enough. Deepwater Horizon is such a story. It should be an uplifting true drama of real people fighting to survive and get
back to their families. It should feel compelling. Instead, if feels dull. Peter Berg is bored and it shows.
P.S. "Patriots Day" has a better script and story (more action, more twists & turns, more characters) which saves it
from Deepwater Horizon's monotonous fate.